The controversies swirling around Pakistan’s judiciary have once again thrust the institution into the limelight, sparking intense scrutiny of its decisions and casting doubts on their integrity. Recent rulings by the current Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, particularly in the case of Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, have reignited longstanding debates, with lingering concerns over the evidentiary basis of these verdicts. While Chief Justice Faiz Isa’s recent interventions may not have been directly tied to the Bhutto case, they have nonetheless raised serious questions about the judiciary’s adherence to legal principles in recent years. His critique of a prior ruling, which he deemed legally flawed, and his subsequent call for the removal of Justice Shaukat Aziz Siddiqui, have highlighted the pressing need for transparency and accountability within the judicial system. In response to these developments, a group of six judges from the Islamabad High Court has taken a courageous stance by demanding a judicial convention from the Supreme Judicial Council. Their collective statement underscores the glaring inconsistency surrounding Justice Siddiqui’s dismissal in 2018, during which he alleged undue interference by intelligence agencies.
The judges’ written appeal serves as a clarion call for rectifying this discrepancy and ensuring that justice is dispensed impartially and without external influence. By shining a light on instances of potential judicial misconduct and advocating for thorough investigations, these judges are championing the principles of transparency and accountability that are essential to upholding the rule of law. As guardians of justice, it is incumbent upon the judiciary to operate with the utmost integrity and independence, safeguarding the rights of all individuals and upholding the principles of fairness and equity. Only through a steadfast commitment to transparency and accountability can the judiciary maintain the public’s trust and fulfill its constitutional mandate as the guardian of justice in Pakistan.
The recent Supreme Court ruling, overturning his removal and labeling him a retired judge, has raised serious questions about the integrity of the judiciary’s decision-making process. The judges’ letter emphasizes the importance of conducting thorough investigations into the allegations raised against Justice (Retired) Shaukat Aziz Siddiqui. It calls for clarity on the individuals responsible for undermining judicial independence and the measures taken to address such interference. Furthermore, it underscores the need for guidelines within the judges’ code of conduct to effectively report and address instances of external influence. At its core, the call for transparency and accountability within the judiciary is essential for upholding the rule of law and preserving public trust in the judicial system. As guardians of justice, it is imperative for judges to operate with integrity, impartiality, and independence, free from external pressures or influences. By addressing the underlying issues and ensuring adherence to established legal principles, Pakistan’s judiciary can reinforce its role as a pillar of democracy and justice in the country.
